man doing a balance comparing traditional and digital marketing

Over the past 25 years, the use of traditional marketing has suffered a steep decline while the digital world has expanded into every facet of our daily lives. But does that make digital marketing better than traditional? Not necessarily.

What’s the Difference?

Let’s start with traditional marketing because it’s the oldest. The concept of traditional marketing dates back centuries and evolved to incorporate new technologies, such as the printing press, then radio, and television. Traditional marketing activities are the following:

  • Newspapers
  • Magazines
  • Radio
  • Billboards
  • Television
  • Direct Mail
  • Catalogs and Brochures
  • Telemarketing

The internet changed marketing in one major way; It created an entirely new world, the virtual world. Digital marketing continues to rapidly evolve with technology, yet much of it has been around for many years:

  • Email
  • Text
  • Blogs and Vlogs
  • Social media
  • Video
  • Banner ads
  • Pay-Per-Click

Comparing Traditional and Digital Marketing: Is One Better Than the Other?

Even though traditional marketing seems to be slowly going away, it’s very relevant for small and mid-sized businesses. And digital marketing isn’t the only thing a company should be focused on. Comparing traditional and digital marketing, there are many advantages and disadvantages for both. The key is understanding how they work with consumers and utilizing them to their fullest potential.

Traditional Marketing

Advantages

Broadcast media and billboards have the ability to reach a larger local audience, therefore casting a wider net. Newspapers and magazines are viewed as credible sources of information for targeted audiences. Printed material, such as direct mail, gives people a hard copy which leads to multiple impressions that last much longer.

Disadvantages

The primary disadvantage is that traditional marketing is expensive. Another disadvantage is calculating return on investment. Plus, any mistakes can be costly.

Digital Marketing

Advantages

Regardless of location, websites and social media can reach a global audience. It can also target audiences with near perfect precision. Tailored content to drive more engagement. Digital is more cost-effective and measuring the return on investment is easier to calculate.

Disadvantages

There is a major “knowledge curve” with regard to digital marketing. It takes a lot of research and time to understand what works and what doesn’t. Outside help is often necessary. Search engines are the gatekeepers of information, which makes it difficult and expensive to get in front of potential customers. Because it’s so precise, it’s much more difficult to cast a wider net to local audiences.

Who Is The Audience?

A recent case study of two furniture retailers found the advantages and disadvantages of both forms of marketing to be true. One retailer in the study used primarily traditional methods to advertise, while the other focused on digital. Both were successful and had similar overall returns on their investment, but in different ways: new customers and repeat customers.

Traditional marketing brought more people to the showroom and almost twice as many new customers to the store. Whereas digital marketing engaged with repeat customers and had a much higher close rate on sales for that group.

For retailers looking to bring in new customers, traditional marketing has a broader reach and captures more attention than digital. But, if retailers want to engage more with the customers they have, which tend to be the most profitable, they need to focus on their digital marketing efforts. The conclusion from this study is that a strategic mix of both will bring in the highest returns.

Resources: